Comparisons
Comparisons
Almost every choice in a smart home is a trade of convenience for independence or of simplicity for flexibility. A device that connects in a couple of minutes may stop responding without the internet, while a dependable local system takes more time to learn. Below we compare general approaches rather than specific products, to make it easier for you to decide what suits your household.
The more important the task, the less it should depend on someone else's server far away from your home.
How to read the tables: we compare approaches, not products. What your device can do is stated in its description and manual, and if they say otherwise, trust them.
Via Wi-Fi or via a hub
| Criterion | Directly over Wi-Fi | Through a hub |
|---|---|---|
| How it works | Each device connects to the home router on its own | Sensors and bulbs talk to a separate hub box, and the hub talks to the router |
| What you need to get started | Just a router and an app | The hub itself, a place to put it and a little patience during the first setup |
| Load on the home network | Each device takes a place on the network, and with many of them the router may struggle | The network sees only the hub, while the sensors communicate with it in their own way |
| Batteries | Battery-powered devices drain faster with this kind of connection | Small battery-powered sensors usually last noticeably longer |
| Who it suits | People with a couple of plugs and bulbs who have no wish to dig into the setup | People planning lots of sensors who want some scenes to work without the internet |
Cloud or local control
| Criterion | Cloud control | Local control |
|---|---|---|
| Where commands run | On the manufacturer's servers, where the device sends data and from which it receives commands | Inside your home: on the hub or on the device itself |
| Without the internet | Some features, and sometimes all of them, stop working | Simple scenes keep running |
| Response speed | There can be a noticeable delay, especially on a weak connection | Usually faster, because the command doesn't have to leave the house |
| Privacy | Data about when you are home and what you use is stored by the manufacturer | More information stays with you, but you have to look after the system yourself |
| Control away from home | Works straight after setup | Often needs extra steps and attention to security |
One ecosystem or different makers
| Criterion | Everything from one maker | Devices from different makers |
|---|---|---|
| Setup | One app, a consistent style and clear prompts | Possibly several apps or a shared hub that has to be made to work with all of them |
| Choice of devices | Limited to what this maker produces | You can pick whatever suits each task best |
| Lock-in risks | If the maker ends support or changes its terms, the whole home is affected at once | One maker pulling out affects only some of your devices |
| Scenes | As a rule, easy to build within a single app | Linking devices from different systems can be tricky, and some features may be unavailable |
| Who it suits | People who value simplicity and don't want to deal with compatibility | People willing to spend time on setup for the sake of flexibility and independence |
Read next
- Guides
Step-by-step advice: your first plug, motion-activated lights, leak alerts, guest access for the family. The article catalogue lives here too.
- Tools
What to gather before buying and setting up: a task list, a sketch of rooms and sockets, a guest network, a password store and device manuals.
- Problems
A device shows as offline, a scene does nothing, commands arrive late, a sensor triggers for no reason, batteries drain too fast.
- Glossary
A plain-language glossary: sensor, scene, automation, hub, cloud, local control, ecosystem, guest network.
- Questions
Answers about the guide, about choosing devices and getting them to work together, about cameras, microphones and access for the household.
Sources
- Device manuals and specification sheets from manufacturers (in general terms)
- Security recommendations for home network devices (in general terms)
- Editorial materials of the Proshivki All guide
The texts in this guide are written in general terms and reflect the editors' view as of the date they were prepared. Smart devices from different makers are set up in their own ways, and buttons and menu items in apps get moved and renamed from time to time. If your device's manual or specification sheet tells you to do something differently from us, trust it.